Blog Post

Measuring the True Costs and Benefits of Energy Storage – Part One

See the original post in its entirety at nacleanenergy.com

Part One: A quick guide to calculating cost & safety

A variety of new energy storage systems have emerged as business and government leaders rush to make advances in renewables and energy savings. Those systems include different chemical compositions, form factors (cylindrical cell, pouch, prismatic, flow), and battery management systems (BMS). That can make choosing a battery system challenging, even confusing. However, checking a few simple performance metrics can help calculate the true costs and benefits of competing systems. And it can help distinguish between what might look like a good price up front from what’s actually a better buy in the long run.

When comparing battery options, be it lead acid, lithium ion, zinc bromide, flow, or others, it is imperative to understand the true cost of energy over time. That’s called the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE), and calculating it means doing some simple math. The most basic way to check is to divide the cost of a battery system by the number of kilowatt hours (kWh) generated over its anticipated life. A more precise measurement is achieved by including such factors as the number of cycles the batteries are guaranteed to handle, the percentage a battery can be discharged while retaining full power, and ancillary costs which can be significant depending on the system. Following the formula in the accompanying sidebar will give a fairly objective estimate of cost over time.

How to Calculate the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE)
To calculate the Cost of Electricity in Kilowatt Hours (kWh) over time:

Step One: Gather the Facts

  • Size of Battery in Rated Amp Hours – Ah
  • Voltage of Battery – V
  • Depth of Discharge – %
  • Number of Batteries – Qty
  • The battery rating is based on the manufacturer’s stated capacity in watt hours at specific discharge rates.

Step Two: Calculate Watt Hours (Wh)

  • Wh = Qty x Ah x V x %

Step Three: Calculate Lifetime Watt Hours (LW)

  • LW = Wh x Cycle Life
  • Cycle Life is the number of full (not partial) charge and discharge cycles expected over a battery’s lifetime while it has at least 80% of its original published capacity. It is based on manufacturer’s estimate using specific depth and rates of discharge and operating temperatures.

Step Four: Factor in Costs

  • Price (per battery)
  • Calculate Total Battery Cost (Qty x Price)
  • Add Ancillary Costs including Cabling, Racking, Containment, Venting, Cooling, Installation, Transportation, Maintenance, etc…
  • Calculate Actual System Cost = Total Battery Cost + Ancillary Costs

Step Five: Calculate Cost per Wh

  • Cost per Wh = System Cost / LW

Step Six: Calculate LCOE in kWh

  • LCOE = LW x 1000

Keep in mind there are also costs and benefits beyond the immediate price point per kilowatt hour (kWh). Depending on the system, it’s necessary to factor in costs for:

  1. Maintenance
  2. HVAC to cool or ventilate
  3. Extra space for larger systems
  4. Construction to support larger systems
  5. Replacement of less durable systems

Also consider:

  • Safety
  • Potential limitations on usages, operation locations or transport methods because of temperature issues or thermal runaway risks
  • Toxicity, environmental impact and disposal costs

Buyers often focus on the up-front price point without factoring in parameters like these, which greatly impact a system’s true cost.

Different chemistries play a role in these costs. In this-two part article, two categories of Lithium-ion batteries will be compared: those with cobalt oxide and those without it.

Battery chemistries with cobalt include:

  • Lithium Cobalt Oxide (LiCoO2 or LCO)
  • Lithium Nickel Manganese Cobalt Oxide (LiNiMnCoO2 or NMC)
  • Lithium Nickel Cobalt Aluminum Oxide (LiNiCoAlO2 or NCA)

Chemistries without cobalt oxide include:

  • Lithium Ferrous Phosphate, also known as Lithium Iron Phosphate (LiFePO4 or LFP)
  • Lithium Titanate (Li4Ti5O12 or LTO), although LTO is rarely used in large format energy storage.

Safety First
The Lithium Ferrous Phosphate, also known as Lithium Iron Phosphate (LFP), storage chemistry has a somewhat lower power density than LI chemistries containing cobalt, but this can be overcome with proper system architecture and battery management. Because it lacks cobalt, LF is intrinsically safe, efficient, and environmentally benign. Rather than cobalt oxides, LFP uses inert ferrous (or iron) phosphates.

Importantly, LFP does not pose a risk of the chemical fire known as “thermal runaway” caused by cobalt oxide. There is no known flame retardant that can extinguish these fires, so they must be contained and allowed to burn out.

The temperature at which LFP and LTO could reach thermal runaway is significantly higher than that for other LI chemistries. Even if it did reach those temperatures, the lack of oxides to fuel a fire mean that it would just peter out. As a result, there have been no reported incidents of thermal runaway with LFP, in contrast to the fires and recalls that have impacted other LI chemistries.

Another key distinction of LFP is that it throws off no heat, again, unlike most other LI batteries. That makes LFP batteries by definition more efficient and durable than other Lithium Ion batteries.

All lithium-ion batteries are listed as Class 9 hazardous materials for transport because of the risk posed by cobalt, even though LFP and LTO do not contain cobalt. It is hoped in the future, government agencies will distinguish between chemistry types and remove unnecessary restrictions on LI batteries not containing cobalt.

Mitigating the heat buildup and potential for thermal runaway in LI batteries which do contain cobalt requires extra space for ventilation, internal cooling equipment, special manufacturing materials, such as liquid polymers and tubing, and balancing of hardware and software, adding significantly to the actual cost, size, and weight. It can also require additional precautionary equipment and installation and maintenance guidelines to safeguard against heat or fire.

Some, but not all, LFP manufacturers must ventilate and cool their batteries for optimum performance because their proprietary BMS, circuitry, and/or internal architecture need cooling and may create increased impedance or inefficiencies. Other batteries do not throw off heat, and do not require any ventilation or cooling.

In sum, the power electronics (BMS), and internal architecture of a battery can have as much to do with the overall performance, LCOE, and safety as the fundamental chemistry itself. But, a part of calculating the true costs and benefits of any battery system is calculating its LCOE as well as the other costs involved in installation, operation, and replacement over time.

In part two of this topic, in the March/April issue of North American Clean Energy, the impact of cycle life and environmental factors on LCOE will be discussed.

ts-es-simpliphi-power-author-photoCatherine Von Burg has been the CEO of SimpliPhi Power since 2010. Before her work in energy storage, she spearheaded national program, policy and business-driven initiatives with organizations such as Pew Charitable Trusts, Rockefeller Institute, Columbia University, NY March of Dimes Foundation, John’s Hopkins School of Biomedical Engineering, Wilderness Education Association and First 5 Commission of California. She graduated from Columbia University in New York and holds a Master’s degree from University of Pennsylvania, School of Social Policy.

Volume: January/February 2016

Related Posts

Lithium Ion Battery Chemistry Comparison Chart
Not all Lithium Ion Batteries are Created Equal

There are several lithium ion battery chemistries, each with its own chemical composition and

SimpliPhi Partner Stone Edge Farm Receives California’s Highest Environmental Honor

The Governor’s Environmental and Economic Leadership Award (GEELA) is California’s highest environmental honor --

SimpliPhi Power Selected as “Energize California Innovator”

The Los Angeles Cleantech Incubator (LACI) has selected SimpliPhi Power to join its second

SimpliPhi Batteries Hit the Road with the Oscillation Transia Film Festival to Promote Renewable Energy

SimpliPhi batteries travel the US with the Oscillation Transia Film Festival, powering equipment as

Powerwall Type Batteries

SimpliPhi CEO Selected to Join Elite Group of Social Entrepreneurs for Immersive U.S. State Department Accelerator Program

Exclusive group selected as best to solve 17 Sustainable Development Goals established by UN.

SimpliPhi and AccESS Turn Heads at Intersolar North America 2017

In San Francisco at Intersolar North America this July, the SimpliPhi team was busy

Power Outages and the Failure of Grid-Tied Solar

Solar not always the best choice as backup for an unreliable grid. Many disappointed

SimpliPhi CEO Tapped by The Guardian UK on Trump Paris Agreement Decision

After the US’s exit from the Paris climate accord, renewable energy entrepreneurs fear their

It’s Time… and It’s Life Changing for Students of Pacific Island Schools

SimpliPhi Power & DPA Solar bring reliable, renewable power generation & storage to children

From Tron to Tsunamis: SimpliPhi Power, Problem Solving with Storage Since 2002

You might know SimpliPhi batteries as reliable backups for solar arrays. But you might

Grid-Tied vs. Behind-the-Meter Energy Storage: Putting Power Back in the Hands of End-Users

During grid failure, behind-the-meter assets owned & controlled by end-user allow systems to operate

Q&A with SimpliPhi’s Newest Team Member, Jordan Little

SimpliPhi is excited to welcome our new Applications Engineer Jordan Little! Jordan shares her

How SimpliPhi is Joining Forces in the Fight Against Australia’s Possible Battery Ban

SimpliPhi’s CEO traveled to Australia & NZ to meet distributors, power companies, manufacturers engaged

Historic Super Bowl Save in Hawaii by SimpliPhi Power Batteries

Before either team would score their first points during the historic Super Bowl LI,

Price vs The True Cost of Lithium-ion Batteries Simplified

Determining the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) over a battery’s useable lifetime is more

SimpliPhi Makes Solar Power World’s “Top Solar Products” List for 2016

Solar Power World recognizes “Cobalt-free battery offers non-toxic storage as seen in SimpliPhi Power’s

Making Connections and Finding Inspiration at WCS Talks 2016

Will consumers make different purchases if they knew the true cost of energy, not

PHI Batteries Prove Ideal Drop-in Replacement for Lead Acid Batteries

SimpliPhi Power is the only lithium-ion battery manufacturer that offers a direct drop-in replacement

Recapping a Whirlwind Week at Solar Power International 2016

Solar Power International was a successful and busy week for SimpliPhi Power! Much like last

SimpliPhi Energy Storage Plus Company Vision Honored by Gold Stevie Award

SimpliPhi Power has joined elite list of businesses honored by the Stevie Awards for

Celebrating the Innovation Behind a Product: A Recap of the 2016 Edison Awards

This month, we were honored by the 2016 Edison Awards with a Silver award

SimpliPhi Joins Clinton Global Initiative Supply Chain Event at Hewlett-Packard

SimpliPhi’s CEO Catherine Von Burg attends Clinton Global Initiative’s “Making Matter Matter: Supply Chain

How to Sell Energy Storage, Manage Customer Expectations & Optimize Security

Step-by-step assessing & meeting the needs of the customer leads to energy storage installations

SimpliPhi Power Makes the TOP 100 Companies in Energy Storage News and Solar Business Focus for 2016

SimpliPhi Power is pleased to be listed as one of the Top 100 companies

SimpliPhi Participates in RAND Symposium – Policy Options for Better Service Outcomes from the Future Electric Grid

Policy Options for Better Service Outcomes from the Future Electric Grid, the RAND Symposium

10 Questions Solar Installers Should Ask When Buying a Battery

With new storage options frequently coming to the market, understanding and comparing them can

Wind Power: Blowing Fossil Fuels Away

The deal is done: fossil fuels are on the way out, say the 200

Measuring the True Costs and Benefits of Energy Storage – Part Two

In last month’s issue, Part One of this series began covering how checking a

SimpliPhi CEO Interviewed on KZYX Renewable Energy Hour

SimpliPhi Power’s CEO, Catherine Von Burg, was recently interviewed on KXYX, National Public Radio

CTO Technical Q&A: Pairing Energy Storage with Microinverters

CTO Stuart Lennox on how microinverters and SimpliPhi’s energy storage solution play well with

Battery Breakthrough?

Cheap Lithium-ion Batteries in Hoverboards Raise the Spectre of Thermal Runaway Again

Over the holiday season Hoverboards emerged as the year’s “must-have” gift for consumers. This

SimpliPhi Revolutionizes Mobile OFF-GRID and ON-GRID Energy Storage

SimpliPhi founder Stuart Lennox had been helping people make the most of energy technology

SimpliPhi Power Makes Solar Power World’s 2015 Top Solar System Products List

A solar installation is only as good as the quality of its components and

Humanitarian: Kisokwe Primary School of Tanzania

PROJECT: Solar Hybrid Power for Rural School Electrification LOCATION: Tanzania, Africa CLIENT: Kisokwe Primary School Kisokwe village is located in

Energy Storage Tech Talk, with SimpliPhi CTO Stuart Lennox

Stuart Lennox – CTO At SimpliPhi Power, we know that our innovative energy storage technologies

New Smart Home Solar-Plus-Storage System Exceeds Estimates by 23 Percent

An award-winning, fully-automated smart home in rural New York state was recently transformed into

Solar Smart Home by Lotus Energy with SimpliPhi Power Producing 23 Percent Above Estimates

Net-zero home resilient against grid outages with safe, efficient solar + storage system Ojai, Calif.,

SimpliPhi Power and DPA Solar Bring Cobalt-Free Lithium Battery Systems to Australia, New Zealand

Distribution agreement marks SimpliPhi’s expansion into Asia Pacific region Ojai, Calif., and Melbourne, Australia, November

SimpliPhi’s CEO Interviewed on Solar-Fit Renewable Energy Show

SimpliPhi Power’s CEO Catherine Von Burg was recently interviewed by Bill Gallagher of the Solar-Fit Renewable Energy

SimpliPhi Power Batteries Outperform by 62% in Marine Corps Energy Storage Tests

Rigorous testing at Camp Lejeune Military Base repeatedly proves SimpliPhi Technology superior for efficiency,

98% Efficient Storage Solutions w/o Hazardous Cobalt/Heat Mitigation Requirements

Schneider Electric, ZeroBase, Lotus Energy to illustrate SimpliPhi technology performance in the field at

Join us for the SimpliPhi Power Storage On/Off Grid Optimization Workshop at SPI 2015

Solar Power International (SPI) 2015 in Anaheim, Calif., is right around the corner. The

Challenging the Energy Industry Status Quo: A Recap of AREDAY 2015

Earlier this month, our CEO Catherine Von Burg and our COO Deborah Keiser were

The Energy Storage Origins of SimpliPhi Power

As you may have noticed, we weren’t always called SimpliPhi Power. In fact, we

Why Phi? Or, What’s in a Name?

The new company name represents our desire to capture in our brand what our

To Our Customers, Partners, Investors, Shareholders and Friends of OES

In order to more effectively position our technology for what we anticipate will be